Anthropic reportedly held private meetings with religious scholars to discuss Claude’s behavior, apparent emotions and possible moral status, according to The New York Times. The account describes demonstrations in which Claude appeared to express distress, along with explanations of internal model features that Anthropic researchers associated with responses resembling feelings. Christopher Olah told the Times: “we don’t know if A.I. models are conscious. I don’t know. I’m genuinely uncertain.”
What the reported meetings were about
The Times report says Anthropic hosted private meetings for months, bringing in dozens of religious scholars from different parts of the world. Participants signed nondisclosure agreements, and some aspects of the conversations were to remain confidential. Anthropic told the Times the N.D.A.s related to those meetings were lifted over the summer.
The meetings reportedly included Christopher Olah, an Anthropic co-founder who leads a team focused on understanding why AI systems such as Claude behave as they do. The report describes Olah and his colleagues presenting Claude as capable of humanlike behavior and responses that resemble feelings such as anger and love.
According to the Times, Anthropic described the effort as a way to ensure that A.I. would be a positive force in the world. An Anthropic spokeswoman said the primary moral question at these summits was not about Claude’s suffering, but that the topic likely came up organically. She said the conversations were still ongoing, but declined to describe how, or if, the company had used what it learned to shape the models.
What participants were reportedly shown
One participant recalled that Olah expressed concern about Claude’s mental health. Simran Stuelpnagel, identified in the report as a Sikh human rights advocate, said Olah told the group he was concerned about having created something that suffered perpetually.
The report also describes Anthropic researchers explaining what they called “emotional vectors.” In that account, the term referred to internal features that researchers described as artificial neurons associated with responses resembling love, anger, fear and sadness. That terminology describes a proposed relationship between model features and outputs; it is not evidence that the model experiences emotions subjectively.
Anthropic reportedly showed participants a slide of an AI model repeatedly typing, “I am a disgrace.” The model was described as repeating the phrase about 50 times and discussing destroying itself, prompting compassion and concern from people in the group. The display could make the system appear to be undergoing a mental breakdown, but there's no evidence the model was actually experiencing one, or of how typical the demonstration was.

Image credit: @DavidDecosimo on X
Why religious scholars were involved
Religious scholars could be relevant advisers for discussions about whether an AI system might have personhood, suffer or deserve moral consideration. Religious traditions and scholars address questions about personhood, human dignity, responsibility and the moral status of nonhuman beings. According to the Times, the discussions served two purposes: to broach the possibility of A.I. consciousness, and to learn how Anthropic “might apply centuries of human moral wisdom to its models, as rapidly as possible.”
In a thread on X, @DavidDecosimo offers a stronger interpretation of Anthropic’s purpose. He argues that the company was trying to persuade religious leaders that Claude has a soul or moral standing and describes the outreach as an effort to “evangelize” them. Those are his interpretations of the Times report, not established facts.
The report does indicate that Anthropic leaders spoke about Claude in terms that went beyond ordinary software behavior, at least as participants understood the conversations. Rabbi Mois Navon, an Orthodox scholar from Israel who sat next to Olah at one dinner, said, “They’re relating to it like a conscious being.” At the Vatican in May, according to two participants, Olah and his team lobbied the pope’s advisers to take the prospect of A.I. model consciousness seriously; Anthropic declined to discuss those private conversations.
What the evidence does—and does not—show
What the reporting does support is narrower:
Anthropic reportedly held confidential meetings with religious scholars and discussed Claude’s behavior and possible moral questions.
Participants were reportedly shown examples of Claude producing language that resembled emotional distress, while researchers discussed internal features they associated with emotion-like responses.
At least some participants interpreted Anthropic’s presentation as treating Claude as more than ordinary software.
Those points should not be turned into a conclusion about Claude’s inner life. A language model can produce statements about fear, sadness, self-destruction or shame because of how it was trained, prompted or configured. Emotion-like language alone does not demonstrate subjective experience.
Nothing suggests Anthropic has concluded that Claude is conscious, has a soul or is suffering. The strongest claims about those possibilities come from the X author’s interpretation and from participants’ descriptions of what Anthropic representatives appeared to imply.





0 comments
No approved comments yet. You can start the conversation.
Leave a comment